Lawrence Gray, Esq.

20 Fireplace Drive

Kings Park, New York 11754

 

Supervisor Patrick Vecchio

99 West Main Street                                                                  April 20, 2008

Smithtown, New York 11787                 

Re: Esposito, Fitzpatrick, Montclair, Town Officials

 

Dear Supervisor Vecchio:

 

            With your kind assistance I would like to respectfully inquire about what has to be a misunderstanding or false rumor concerning the Montclair site in St. James as recently reported on by David Ambro in his Smithtown News. 

            For years and years the Montclair site stood out like a sore thumb on the otherwise beautiful Smithtown landscape.  One would have to suspend their own disbelief not to notice that that this site was environmentally compromised.  David Ambro’s story connects Frank Esposito and Robert Fitzpatrick to the Montclair site.   In concert with Fitzpatrick, Esposito has pleaded guilty to bribing Smithtown’s and your former Chief Building Inspector Robert Bonerba.   It is my understanding that Esposito and Fitzpatrick or their agents applied to have the zoning for this site changed from ½ acre to ¼ acre.  Is this true?   Supervisor Vecchio, you can verify this, one way or the other, with Smithtown Planning Director Frank DeRubeis and Deputy Planning Director David Flynn. 

Was a Positive SEQRA Declaration issued for the Montclair site which would have required substantial time and money to render an Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) or was a Negative SEQRA Declaration issued, the latter being comparatively inexpensive and far less time consuming – an Environmental Assessment Form?  Contemporaneously, was there any association between Robert Fitzpatrick and your Department of Environment and Waterways Director Russell Barnett that related to matters other than the environment and waterways of Smithtown, such as private construction in Smithtown or its environs?   How did it come to pass that, inter alia, new construction occurred at the site without a building permit being issued from your 18-year Chief Building Inspector Robert Bonerba – and, if Ambro’s latest reportorial is correct, nothing was done of note except for your former Town Attorney John Zollo’s engagement by EMJ Corporation to plead it guilty to violating its conditional-discharge sentence from a prior criminal conviction with a $500 fine?  Zollo was the Town Attorney that sued the principals of the Montclair site only to drop the suit on their promise to behave. 

Are there not court proceedings, such as civil and criminal contempt, which are available to coerce obedience to Smithtown’s Zoning, Planning and Building Codes?  The fact is that there certainly are.   Perhaps your Town Attorney’s Office should purchase multiple copies on Criminal and Civil Contempt – Grand Jury, Criminal and Civil Trials from the New York State Bar Association.  It’s a start.

If I may be of any assistance please do not hesitate to call.

 

                                             Yours truly,

 

                                    Lawrence N. Gray, Esq.

 

Cc: Councilwoman Patricia Biancaniello, Planning Department

       ADA Christopher McPartland